Natural Stone Firepit vs Fireplace: How to Choose Your Best Option

There are many great reasons for adding a natural stone fire feature to an outdoor living space: extending outdoor fun into cooler months, providing a gathering place to enjoy with family and friends, and adding visual appeal to the landscape design. When it comes to deciding whether a fireplace or a firepit is the right choice for you, here are four factors to consider. 

Exterior fireplace by BC Murphy Landscape featuring Greenwich Blue supplied by Southridge Farm Nursery.

1. Aesthetic 

Both firepits and fireplaces are available in various shapes and sizes, can be customized to suit different styles, and can incorporate natural stone. The circular shape of a firepit offers a space to gather around, which creates an optimal space for socializing. A fireplace is a classic option and creates a more formal focal point in your outdoor living area. Natural stone veneer can enhance the visual appeal of either; flagstone is also a popular material for fire pit surrounds and patios, which often accompany exterior fireplaces.

2. Functionality 

Firepits are known for their versatility, and the 360-degree view allows everyone to enjoy the warmth and atmosphere. Firepits also make it easy to do cooking activities, like grilling or roasting marshmallows, making it an appealing option for casual entertainment. Fireplaces offer a cozy, intimate setting, and can serve as an extension of indoor space for get-togethers, as they are often part of a larger entertainment area. An added benefit of fireplaces is that they're designed to direct smoke upward, creating a more comfortable (and smoke-free) atmosphere. 

Connecticut Blend fire pit and seating wall by Legacy Landscape, with stone (also) supplied by Southridge Farm Nursery.

3. Space 

In general, firepits are easier to install and require less space. They can be freestanding or built into existing structures, which makes them flexible and suitable for a variety of outdoor settings. A natural stone fireplace requires more planning, construction, and the skilled craftsmanship of a mason, and defines an area dedicated to outdoor seating and entertainment.

4. Cost 

Firepits are typically more budget-friendly because of their simple design and installation. For an exterior fireplace, the level of detail in the design and installation determines the cost, which in the long-term, may be a worthwhile investment in leisure as well as in the value of the property itself. 

Both firepits and fireplaces can be attractive features in any outdoor living space, depending on your needs, style, and space. Whichever you choose, the best part of a natural stone fire feature is making memories with family and friends in what is sure to be a favorite spot. For more ways to incorporate natural stone into any aspect of your home design, download our Natural Stone Residential Design Guide.